Tidak cukup dimanipulasi media, Menteri Besar Melaka Dato' Ali Rustam turut mengambil kesempatan 'menyerang' kerajaan Selangor sedangkan Melaka pernah mencetuskan kontroversi berkaitan isu penternakan babi.
"Tahniah kepada kerajaan Selangor kerana meluluskan cadangan untuk membina ladang ternakan babi bernilai RM100 juta di Sepang.
"Sesungguhnya usaha yang dilakukan oleh kerajaan baru gabungan KeADILan, DAP dan PAS ini adalah sebagai hadiah kepada para pengundi yang menyokong parti mereka, termasuk para pengundi beragama Islam pada pilihan raya umum lalu," katanya.
Beliau berkata demikian dalam blog mohdalirustam.blogspot.com dan turut mengakui bahawa isu babi telah lama menjadi masalah di negeri Melaka dan kerajaan negeri sentiasa bersikap bahawa ternakan babi hanyalah untuk keperluan dalam negeri dan bukannya untuk tujuan eksport.
Bagaimana pun pandangan beliau disanggah oleh hampir kesemua pemberi komen dalam blognya yang tidak setuju termasuk mengkritik Ali Rustam yang dilihat tidak bijak dan matang dalam mengemukakan pendapat berhubung isu terbabit.
"Babi adalah sumber makanan kaum bukan Islam tapi tanggungjawab kita sebagai pemimpin Islam untuk sediakan tempat yang selamat dan tidak mencemarkan alam sekitar. Ini adalah tuntutan fardhu kifayah . Bukan macam Dato' cari populariti dengan isu babi...," kata pemberi komen yang dikenali sebagai Rustam.
Dalam pada itu Sifu Apek dalam komennya menyatakan bahawa cadangan di Selangor itu wajar dirujuk oleh kerajaan Melaka kerana kemungkinan pengurusan ladang itu adalah lebih baik daripada yang dilaksanakan Ali Rustam.
"Mengurangkan jumlah babi tidak menyelesaikan masalah termasuk menutup ladang babi. Tetapi apa yang dibuat oleh Kerajaan Pakatan Rakyat adalah kaedah lebih baik dan terancang mangambil kira pandangan semua pihak," kata waikatomalaysians dalam bahasa Inggeris.
"Patutlah isu penternakan babi di Melaka tidak dapat diselesaikan hingga membawa kepada rusuhan. Patutlah Timbalan PM terpaksa campur tangan dan menyelesaikannya," kata seoarang yang mahu dikenali sebagai Jebat Setia yng dilihat turut sependapat dengan pemberi komen yang lain.
Ini termasuk Zul, yang kesal dengan pandangan Ali Rustam itu dan menyatakan bahawa tidak boleh menafikan hak semua penduduk Malaysia berkaitan perakara tersebut.
"Jangan nafikan hak semua penduduk Malaysia..bak kata pemimpin pas.. orang cina pun punyai hak mereka...
"Kenapa harus ditentang suatu sistem yang lebih baik untuk semua... semata mata kerana kalah pada pilihanraya orang yang sebelum ni sokong pun bertukar jadi tak sokong...mana maruah? orang umno tak bermaruah ke?," katanya.
1 comment:
hhmm, i not trying to be too islamist or nationalist in this issue.
ok, first, we must acknowledge that malaysia is not totally malays country; there are chinese and indians.
in islam, we must cater other races' or religions' needs. in this case, some malaysians eat babi.
some say why don't we transfer the babi farm to isolated place; selangor is a big country. i might say, if we do that, maybe the local gov (or the farmers) have to build special road leading to the isolated babi farm which both parties may disagree.
so, that 's not quite brilliant idea.
hhmm, is there any exact rules regarding distance of factories/farms from housing lot? if the new farm is legally within the law, then i think nobody can argue the matter.
but, that might not be the best answer to give to the residents.
hhmm, i think what the new gov can do is to convince the concerned residents about their health or surrounding environment in the near future meaning, let say every month or what, there will be a team of environment experts taking samples from say river, air or whatever associated with environment and analyse them. then , new gov can publicly publish the statistics maybe in official blog, website, press conference to maintain people confidence in the progress/ effectiveness of the project.
maybe, the new gov can set up special clinics or improve health facilities (existing clinic) for residents near the babi farm.
maybe can give medicine periodically to the residents to avoid any infection just in case.
maybe can grow more (big) trees surrounding the new babi farm or near the the farm. i mean, a lot of it.
we cannot get away from this issue simply by not building the farm. somewhere and some time, some states have to build this babi farm too if it is not melaka or selangor because of babi- eater people; we have to cater their needs as malaysians too.
what we can do now is how to reduce the impact of the babi farm. maybe the new gov can publicly announce there will be semburan to prevent the disease caused by the babi say every month or what.
hhmm, maybe we can educate people about the bad affects of eating pork so that in the end, less people eat pork. i don't think pork is something addictive alike cigarette. this might be too idealistic though, but frankly speaking, i don't want my fellow non- muslim or pork eaters to continue to eat something that is not quite healthy as being proved by vast researches conducted even by non- muslim researches and professors.
or we can make pork price higher than chicken, lembu or other daging as what we did (and will do ) to alcohol and cigarette. by doing that, less people will eat pork gradually, kot. the extra money collected from the selling of the pork will finance the semburan, trees planting, vaccine to be given to concerned residents etc. but, i can say, this is a bit overreaction kot.
Post a Comment